Showing posts with label Therapy Dogs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Therapy Dogs. Show all posts

Monday, August 08, 2011

'Courtroom dog' helps young rape victim testify



'Courtroom dog' helps young rape victim testify






August 8, 2011



Dog Helps a Witness Testify, and Legal Questions Follow


By WILLIAM GLABERSON

POUGHKEEPSIE, N.Y. — Rosie, the first judicially approved courtroom dog in New York, was in the witness box here nuzzling a 15-year-old girl who was testifying that her father had raped and impregnated her. Rosie sat by the teenager’s feet. At particularly bad moments, she leaned in.

When the trial ended in June with the father’s conviction, the teenager “was most grateful to Rosie above all,” said David A. Crenshaw, a psychologist who works with the teenager.

“She just kept hugging Rosie,” he continued.

Now an appeal planned by the defense lawyers is placing Rosie at the heart of a legal debate that will test whether there will be more Rosies in courtrooms in New York and, possibly, other states.

Rosie is a golden retriever therapy dog who specializes in comforting people when they are under stress. Both prosecutors and defense lawyers have described her as adorable, though she has been known to slobber.

Prosecutors here noted that she is also in the vanguard of a growing trial trend: in Arizona, Hawaii, Idaho, Indiana and some other states in the last few years, courts have allowed such trained dogs to offer children and other vulnerable witnesses nuzzling solace in front of juries.

The new role for dogs as testimony enablers can, however, raise thorny legal questions. Defense lawyers argue that the dogs may unfairly sway jurors with their cuteness and the natural empathy they attract, whether a witness is telling the truth or not, and some prosecutors insist that the courtroom dogs can be a crucial comfort to those enduring the ordeal of testifying, especially children.

The new witness-stand role for dogs in several states began in 2003, when the prosecution won permission for a dog named Jeeter with a beige button nose to help in a sexual assault case in Seattle. “Sometimes the dog means the difference between a conviction and an acquittal,” said Ellen O’Neill-Stephens, a prosecutor there who has become a campaigner for the dog-in-court cause.

Service dogs have long been permitted in courts. But in a ruling in June that allowed Rosie to accompany the teenage rape victim to the trial here, a Dutchess County Court judge, Stephen L. Greller, said the teenager was traumatized and the defendant, Victor Tohom, appeared threatening.

Although he said there was no precedent in the state, Judge Greller ruled that Rosie was similar to the teddy bear that a New York state appeals court said in 1994 could accompany a child witness.

At least once when the teenager hesitated in Judge Greller’s courtroom, the dog rose and seemed to push the girl gently with her nose. Mr. Tohom was convicted and sentenced to 25 years to life.

His public defenders, David S. Martin and Steven W. Levine, have raised a series of objections that they say seem likely to land the case in New York’s highest court. They argue that as a therapy dog, Rosie responds to people under stress by comforting them, whether the stress comes from confronting a guilty defendant or lying under oath.

But they say jurors are likely to conclude that the dog is helping victims expose the truth. “Every time she stroked the dog,” Mr. Martin said in an interview, “it sent an unconscious message to the jury that she was under stress because she was telling the truth.”

“There was no way for me to cross-examine the dog,” Mr. Martin added.

In written arguments, the defense lawyers claimed it was “prosecutorial misconduct” for the Dutchess County assistant district attorney handling the rape case, Kristine Hawlk, to arrange for Rosie to be taken into the courtroom.

Cute as the dog was, the defense said, Rosie’s presence “infected the trial with such unfairness” that it constituted a violation of their client’s constitutional rights.

Ms. Hawlk declined to discuss Rosie. In written arguments, she said that all Rosie did was help a victim suffering from serious emotional distress, and she called the defense claims “frivolous accusations.”

The defense lawyers acknowledged the risk of appearing antidog. Rosie, they wrote, “is a lovely creature and by all standards a ‘good dog,’ ” and, they added, the defendant “wishes her only the best.”

As the lawyers prepare their appeal, Rosie has been busy. She spent much of her time in recent weeks with two girls, ages 5 and 11, who were getting ready to testify against the man accused of murder in the stabbing of their mother.

The Dutchess prosecutor in that case, Matthew A. Weishaupt, argued that Rosie and dogs like her did not affect the substance of the testimony about horrifying crimes.

“These dogs ease the stress and ease the trauma so a child can take the stand,” Mr. Weishaupt said in an interview.

In the end, Rosie was not needed in the second case: the defendant, Gabriel Lopez-Perez, who had a history of domestic violence, interrupted his trial last week to plead guilty to killing the girls’ mother, his girlfriend, in the Wappingers Falls rooming house where they lived.

But Rosie’s promised appearance next to the children might well have played a role. “It became obvious,” said Mr. Lopez-Perez’s lawyer, Andres Aranda, “that the children were going to be testifying, and he decided to avoid that.”

The defense’s appeal of Rosie’s first courtroom outing, in the rape case, is likely to establish legal principles on the issues of dogs in the witness box. “It is an important case, and appeals courts will consider it an important case,” James A. Cohen, a professor of criminal law at Fordham University School of Law, said.

When New York appeals courts study the question, they are likely to look at the experience of courtroom dogs around the country, including in Washington. In Seattle, a developmentally disabled 57-year-old man, Douglas K. Lare, recently recalled how a Labrador retriever named Ellie, who has made more than 50 court appearances, helped him testify against a man charged with a scheme to steal from him.

Ellie gave him courage when he was afraid, Mr. Lare said in an interview: “It was like I had no other friends in the courthouse except Ellie,” he said.

For 11-year-old Rosie, said her owners, Dale and Lu Picard, the courtroom work is a career change after years working with emotionally troubled children at a residential center in Brewster. The Picards’ organization, Educated Canines Assisting With Disabilities, or ECAD, places service dogs after training them to perform tasks like turning lights on and off and opening doors.

Rosie, named for the civil rights pioneer Rosa Parks, was originally taught to follow 80 commands, including taking off a person’s socks without biting any toes. But she has a special talent with traumatized children, said Dr. Crenshaw, the psychologist who has worked with all three of Rosie’s witnesses and many other troubled children.

“When they start talking about difficult things,” Dr. Crenshaw said, “Rosie picks up on that and goes over and nudges them. I’ve seen it with my own eyes.”


Saturday, April 02, 2011

Santa Barbara Therapy Dog Survives Fighting Ring, but Blood Sport Remains Active

by Cathy Murillo, Santa Barbara Independent
http://www.independent.com/staff/cathy-murillo/


Alison Hansen with Daisy Mae
 Hell to Heaven

The story of Daisy Mae the pit bull is like that of any other survivor- she suffered pain, got back on her feet, and is now living a sweeter, more meaningful life because of her experience.

Daisy Mae, formerly part of a dogfighting operation is now a therapy dog in Santa Barbara making weekly rounds at Cottage Hospital's Pediatric Ward and Villa Riviera retirement home.  Gentle and affectionate, the three year old cuddles with the elderly and frail, and even allows small children to hold her tight when they are undergoing painful medical procedures.

Her miracle of rehabilitation mirrors that of the dogs rescued from the Michael Vick's fight farm, where only one dog had to be euthanized for being vicious.  Of the remaining 47 Vick canines, most have been placed in homes, many with children, other dogs and cats.

While Daisy Mae and the rehabilitated Vick dogs  are changing hearts and minds about the American Pit Bull Terrier,dogfighting continues to be a dark and bloody reality in the United States.  According to the national Humane Society, 99.9% of fighting dogs are Pit Bulls.  And unlike the Vick case where the football player paid rehab costs, most dogs rescued from fight rings are put down because there are no resources to rescue, evaluate, retrain and relocate the animals.

Sack of Potatoes

Daisy Mae's life these days is a stark contrast to her puppy hood.  Found on the streets of Oakland, California in 2006, she was believed to have served as a "bait" dog in a Pit Bull fighting operation.  Dogs without fighting instincts are used to bring out dominance in other dogs.

The brown and white dog was starved and emaciated at 37 pounds.  Not much else is known about Daisy Mae according to her owner, Alison Hansen, 32, a Santa Barbara wedding planning professional.  Hansen found her in a shelter affiliated with the BAD RAP organization, or Bay Area Dog lovers Responsible About Pit bulls (www.badrap.org/rescue).  The dog was extremely withdrawn and frightened, cowering against the wall.

"Something came over me.  I vowed, 'She can never have a bad day again,''" said Hansen who admits to originally wanting an athletic dog she could exercise with.  "I had wanted a Labrador experience, but what I got was a little sack of potatoes."

Daisy Mae's rehabilitation was intense but amazingly quick.  She hadn't been taken for walks or exposed to the world outside of her pen, apparently.  Whenever facing a new experience- a flight of stairs, the sound of a car horn, bicycles, cats- she would freeze up, lie flat on the ground, or pee herself.

Hansen patiently worked with the dog, who eagerly took to training as she wanted to please her new mistress.  Within 4 months, Daisy Mae had mastered all the basic obedience commands (sit, down, stay), earned a Canine Good Citizen (http://www.akc.org/events/cgc) certificate from the American Kennel Club (AKC), and even passed the rigorous testing developed by Therapy Dogs International (http://www.tdi-dog.org/) to become a working volunteer canine (Therapy dog...  not the same as service dog.  To learn more about the differences, please read the following:  http://www.deltasociety.org/Page.aspx?pid=303#Difference).

Two of the Vick dogs are therapy dogs now too.  One is Hector, who is getting national attention for his accomplishment, as he's covered with ugly scars from fighting.  Hansen believes that Hector and Daisy Mae should stand as proof that bad owners are the problem, not bad dogs.  So moved by her dog's transformation, Hansen has joined the campaign against breed-specific legislation.  "It's not fair for cities, counties or states to outlaw all pit bulls," she said.

"These laws are punishing the wrong end of the leash," Hansen said, adding that many pit bull owners don't know they shouldn't drive through Denver, Colorado with their pet.  The breed, even under the care of a nonresident travelers, is subject to being euthanized.  Closer to home, Hansen has to deal with random breed prejudice.  She tells the story of bringing Daisy Mae to a kickball game.  Although the dog was dressed in a silly Pocahontas dog costume, a frightened woman with a small dog yelled at her, "Keep your f---ing dog away from my dog!"

Joe Yuncker and Daisy Mae

Pit Bull Watch

Humane Society officials are wary of all the publicity generated by the Michael Vick pit bull matter.  Yes, many of the dogs were turned around to live happy, normal lives, but the effort cost a lot of money.  Most Pit Bulls are taken from a fighting situation and end up getting the needle.

"You don't hear so much about the abused and neglected dogs that get euthanized," said Adam Goldfarb, a pit bull expert with the Humane Society of the United States.  "Not all dogs are able to recover from traumatic circumstances."

Dog fighting is a felony in all 50 states, and Goldfarb's organization is active in increasing the penalties for spectators at fighting evens and for ownership of fighting dogs.  The Humane Society offers a $5,000 reward for information leading to the conviction of a dog fighter.  Most busts come from anonymous tips because the industry operates underground.

"Some events are huge and charge admission.  Large amounts of money are being wagered," said Goldfarb.  Additionally, other illicit activities (such as drug use & weapons exchange) are part of the scenario.

Goldfarb is not convinced that a true fighting dog can be rehabilitated.  He described a dangerous combination of a dog that wants to kill, and also exhibits the "gameness" that unscrupulous breeders admire.  Gaminess is a trait by which a dog will continue fighting even though she is injured and exhausted.  "You can't place a dog like that in a community."


Daisy Mae hangs out with Wyatt Talor


No one knows this better than Jan Glick, head of Santa Barbara County's Animal Services department.  Her 3 shelters (www.sbcphd.org/as) are full of pit bulls, and she is quick to point out that shelter dogs are screened for aggression against cats, dogs and an extreme prey drive (going after small wildlife etc.) and for compatibility with small children.

"Pit Bulls were bred to be aggressive against other dogs, not people," she said.  Still the public has a fear of the breed, and it's a stigma that is unwarranted in many cases.  Glick also reports that there have been no dogfighting busts in Santa Barbara County, though she believes some fighting activity does take place.  (There are more incidents of cockfighting; Sheriff's authorities raided an 800 chicken ranch 2 weeks ago.)

Glick was glad to hear about Daisy  Mae's success.  "Every dog is an individual and needs to be evaluated that way," she said.  "I encourage people not to think in a breed specific way."